Share to help stimulate good governance, ensure future of people & M’sia
No News Is Bad News
Facebook commentary by Kamsiah Haider but not related to the images
No wonder this house-arrest saga smelled fishy from the beginning. Public records reportedly showed serious concerns over political stability, investor confidence and Malaysia's international reputation. Other board members had reservations, yet the final decision took a different turn, with RM50 million mentioned as a condition. The more documents get declassified, the more this looks like a political thriller where the plot keeps thickening but transparency is still missing. - Facbook
What’s happening to Malaysia’s Justice System?
KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 19, 2026: For this post, No News Is Bad News is refraining from commenting on the issues.
We let the images, found on the internet, do the talking and for Malaysians to form their own judgment.
Thank you! Good for Nation & Citizens to KNOW FULL STORY!
Declassified? By Tony Pua?
TEH.Editorial | ANALYSIS | POLITICS
On Wednesday, five pages of minutes from the 64th meeting of the Federal Territories Pardons Board appeared on Facebook. They were posted by Tony Pua, a former DAP Member of Parliament who holds no government office. The pages show Attorney General Tan Sri Mohd Dusuki Mokhtar and Federal Territories Minister Hannah Yeoh objecting to house arrest for Datuk Seri Najib Razak, and the Yang di Pertuan Agong granting it regardless.
Within hours the contents were national news. The more basic questions remain unanswered: who declassified these pages, under what authority, and why these five.
Who declassified them?
No minister, ministry or agency has announced a declassification. On 12 November, Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail told the Dewan Rakyat that he would propose to Cabinet that the minutes be declassified. The government spokesman later said the proposal had not been discussed directly and that the process was being arranged with the legal requirements in mind.
Six days later, the pages surfaced on a personal social media account. Each carries "Rahsia" at the top left, with both "Terbuka" and "Rahsia" at the bottom right. That suggests a declassification stamp was applied. It does not show who applied it, when, or on whose instruction. The Star and The Rakyat Post describe the documents as alleged minutes. Bernama reported the contents, attributing them to Pua's post.
If the government declassified the minutes, it has not said so. If it did not, a classified state document is now in public circulation.
Why only five pages?
The pages released are numbered 3, 5, 6, 7 and 8. Pages 1, 2 and 4 are missing, along with anything after page 8. The released pages contain the objections of the Attorney General and the minister, and the King's decision. What the missing pages contain is not known.
A selective release is still a release. Someone chose these pages and left out the others.
Umno's questions
Umno information chief Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said has asked for an official explanation. Umno wants to know whether the minutes were formally declassified and when, who authorised it, and the legal basis under Section 2C of the Official Secrets Act 1972. It also wants to know whether the circulating copies match the official record, and whether the declassification covers the full minutes and appendices or only selected parts.
Umno has not disputed what the pages say. Its questions concern process.
What the pages record
According to the minutes, Dusuki told the board that Najib should remain in prison until 2028, in line with the board's earlier position, and that house arrest has no basis in Malaysian law. He cited the December 2025 High Court ruling by Justice Alice Loke. Yeoh said her view was the same as the Attorney General's and consistent with her position at the previous meeting.
Board member Razarudin Husain agreed with the Attorney General but said he would abide by the King's decision. Supri Hashim raised Najib's other pending cases. Former Federal Court judge Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal argued that house arrest could fall within the King's constitutional power to grant reprieves and respites.
The King granted the conditional pardon, with house arrest upon payment of the RM50 million fine. The Federal Constitution gives him that power. The minutes, if genuine, record him using it against the advice of the government's two representatives on the board.
Why did the King name his advisers?
On 7 November, the day after the Attorney General's Chambers suspended Najib's transfer home, Sultan Ibrahim issued a statement. Any challenge to the implementation of his decree, he said, was tantamount to defying it. He noted that the 18 September meeting was attended by the Federal Territories Minister and the Attorney General, who advised him.
The statement did not say what that advice was. Read alone, it placed both officials at the table where the decision was made. The minutes now indicate they advised against it. The Attorney General's Chambers was halting an order that the Attorney General had argued should never have been made.
Why did Loke go and Yeoh stay?
On 10 November, Anthony Loke resigned as Transport Minister in protest over the house arrest, saying it reflected DAP's position. Yeoh had taken the same position inside the Pardons Board in September. She remains in Cabinet.
DAP's answer has been that Loke's resignation was the party's chosen act of protest, and that Yeoh had conveyed views consistent with party principles during deliberations. The minutes support the second half of that answer. They do not explain why one objection cost a minister his post and the other did not.
Principle or positioning?
According to Pua, Yeoh asked for someone else to sign the clemency order and signed only after the King decreed that she do so. That detail is Pua's account. It does not appear in the reported text of the minutes.
If accurate, it shows a minister unwilling to put her name to a decision she opposed. It also shows a minister who signed anyway, and whose refusal is now public through a party colleague's Facebook page, two months later, after DAP's protest had drawn criticism from PAS as symbolic. Both readings fit the facts. The release serves DAP either way.
Who sent the application
On 12 November, in Melaka, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said it was his decision to bring Najib's pardon application to the Pardons Board in 2023. Every prisoner, he said, has the right to appeal to the King. "If I had not allowed it, I would have denied him his right."
That application produced the January 2024 pardon, which halved Najib's sentence to six years and cut his fine from RM210 million to RM50 million. Umno paid the RM50 million on 6 November.
AG, Hannah opposed Najib’s house arrest, declassified minutes show
Two other FTPB members also voiced opposition to the house arrest, with one citing Najib Razak's other pending court cases.
Former prime minister Najib Razak was placed under house arrest on Nov 10 under a conditional pardon after payment of his RM50 million fine in his SRC International case.
PETALING JAYA: Attorney-General Dusuki Mokhtar and federal territories minister Hannah Yeoh were against allowing Najib Razak to be placed under house arrest under a conditional pardon, according to the declassified minutes of the Federal Territories Pardons Board (FTPB) meeting.
According to the minutes, the AG held the view that the former prime minister should complete his reduced sentence in prison, until August 2028.
Dusuki said there were no legal provisions for house arrest under the law, while the move would have implications on political stability, the country’s image at the international level, investments and the economy.
“He stressed that the inmate should continue serving his sentence,” the minutes read, with Yeoh noted as sharing the same views.
Former Federal Court judge Harmindar Singh Dhaliwal, another FTPB member, confirmed that there was no law on house arrest.
However, he said Article 42 of the constitution makes reference to “pardons, reprieves and respites”, and argued that the king could exercise his discretion to grant a “respite”.
Fellow FTPB member Razarudin Husain agreed with the views of the AG but said he would follow the Yang di-Pertuan Agong’s final decision on the matter.
Another board member, Supri Hashim, pointed out that Najib had several other cases pending before the courts, with further jail sentences possible.
Dusuki also said Najib’s bankruptcy proceedings regarding more than RM1.7 billion in tax arrears should be taken into account by the board.
However, Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim said the tax arrears should be ignored as they had no relation to the pardon application and Najib had the right to defend his case in court.
The minutes said the Agong then decided to grant the conditional pardon allowing Najib to serve the remainder of his SRC International sentence under house arrest upon payment of his RM50 million fine.
Najib was jailed in August 2022 after the Federal Court upheld his conviction for abuse of power, criminal breach of trust and money laundering involving RM42 million in SRC International funds. He was sentenced to 12 years in jail and fined RM210 million.
In January 2024, the then Agong, Al-Sultan Abdullah Sultan Ahmad Shah, halved Najib’s prison sentence and reduced his fine to RM50 million as part of a royal pardon.
In September this year, the current Agong, Sultan Ibrahim, granted Najib a further conditional pardon, allowing him to serve the remainder of his sentence under house arrest until Aug 23, 2028.
This was subject to Najib paying the RM50 million fine and complying with other stipulated conditions.
The former Pekan MP was placed under house arrest on Nov 10 after Umno helped pay the fine through crowdfunding.
Hannah wanted another officer to sign Najib’s pardon, minutes show
After considering the pardons board's views, the Agong decided that the FT minister should sign the pardon order since it falls under her responsibility.
Federal territories minister Hannah Yeoh said the conditional pardon would have ‘major political implications and effects’ on the government. (Bernama pic)
PETALING JAYA: Federal territories minister Hannah Yeoh did not want to sign the conditional pardon for former prime minister Najib Razak but eventually relented, according to the declassified minutes of a Federal Territories Pardons Board (FTPB) meeting.
According to the minutes, Yeoh suggested that the pardon order be signed by another officer, such as the chief secretary to the government as the Cabinet secretary.
She cited the “major political implications and effects” the conditional pardon would have on the government.
However, Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim’s special functions officer, Nazim Alim, said it would not be suitable for the chief secretary to sign the order since he was not involved in the meeting. Sultan Ibrahim agreed.
FTPB member Razarudin Husain, meanwhile, said getting someone else to sign the order could create the perception that Yeoh did not attend the meeting.
“After considering the views of the pardons board, the Agong decided that the federal territories minister would sign the conditional pardon order since it fell under her responsibility,” said the minutes.
The FTPB convened at Istana Negara on Sept 18 and adjourned at 9.15am.
Najib was jailed in August 2022 after the Federal Court upheld his conviction for abuse of power, criminal breach of trust and money laundering involving RM42 million in SRC International funds. He was sentenced to 12 years in jail and fined RM210 million.
In January 2024, the then Agong, Al-Sultan Abdullah Sultan Ahmad Shah, halved Najib’s prison sentence and reduced his fine to RM50 million as part of a royal pardon.
In September this year, the current Agong, Sultan Ibrahim, granted Najib a further conditional pardon, allowing him to serve the remainder of his sentence under house arrest until Aug 23, 2028.
This was subject to Najib paying the RM50 million fine and complying with other stipulated conditions.
The former Pekan MP was placed under house arrest on Nov 10 after Umno helped pay the fine through crowdfunding.



















