Extended ‘prison holidays’ for dangerous offenders in Singapore

Share to help stimulate good governance, ensure future of people & M’sia

No News Is Bad News

 For image info, go to https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/prison-conditions-singapore-jail-cells-fan-mattress-shanmugam-2788236 

Extended ‘prison holidays’ for dangerous offenders in Singapore

KUALA LUMPUR, Feb 6, 2024: Singapore yesterday passed a law to “hold dangerous offenders” beyond prison terms.

The law is aimed at those aged above 21 who are convicted of crimes such as culpable homicide, rape, and sex with minors, who are deemed to be at risk of reoffending upon release.

Of course there are many such offenders in Malaysia who qualify for such extended “prison holidays”, especially in Kelantan.

So, will/should Malaysia follow suit with enacting such a law for public safety/to protect our loved ones?

No News Is Bad News reproduces below a news report on the law in Singapore:

Singapore passes law to hold ‘dangerous offenders’ beyond prison terms

The legislation applies to those above 21 convicted of crimes like culpable homicide, rape, and sex with minors.

Reuters - 05 Feb 2024, 10:45pm

The new law means that ‘dangerous offenders’ would need Singapore’s home affairs minister to decide that they were no longer a threat to the public before being released. (Reuters pic)

SINGAPORE: Singapore passed a law today to hold “dangerous offenders” indefinitely, even after they complete their jail sentences.

The legislation applies to those above 21 who are convicted of crimes such as culpable homicide, rape, and sex with minors, who are deemed to be at risk of reoffending upon release.

In a speech in parliament, law and home affairs minister K Shanmugam said, “An offender who continues to pose a real danger to others should not be released.”

He gave an example of a man jailed for raping his 6-year-old stepdaughter, who, after his release started sexually assaulting his sister’s granddaughter who was 10 in 2015. In 2017, he sexually assaulted the girl’s younger sister who was 9.

“We have to deal with these kinds of menace and protect our society,” said Shanmugam.

The new law means that instead of being automatically released after completing their prison terms, such offenders would need the home affairs minister to decide that they were no longer a threat to the public.

The minister would be advised by a review board made up of experts such as retired judges, lawyers, psychiatrists, and psychologists, and the offender and his lawyers can make representations to the board. Those found unfit for release will have their case reviewed annually.

Singapore estimates this law will affect fewer than 30 offenders a year.

The US has a similar law – for sex offenders who are considered likely to reoffend – in 20 states, the District of Columbia, and the federal government.

In Singapore, the law passed with broad support, including from the opposition party, even though some urged caution.

Opposition lawmaker Sylvia Lim, from the Workers’ Party, said it was hard to accurately predict future violence, and there was a risk of “over-detaining someone based on a wrong prediction of dangerousness.”

Lim said judges can already order sentences to run consecutively, which can detain offenders for much of their lives in jail, a preferable option to “leaving it to the executive to determine when an offender should be released.”

Non-governmental organisation Human Rights Watch said it opposed continued detention laws as they violate due process rights.