Share to help stimulate good governance, ensure future of people & M’sia
No News Is Bad News
KUALA LUMPUR, March 27, 2024: The Star has reported the racial and religious bigoted Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh condemning the petrol bomb attack on KK Mart in Perak’s Bidor but says the boycott to go on.
Of course Akmal is emboldened as he looks “untouchable” because the police and the Anwar Ibrahim-led Madani Unity Government (UG) continue to not act against selective bigots like Akmal and Umno.
Akmal can even get away with veiled threats on Malaysians, threatening national unity and harmony.
This is what No News Is Bad News is referring to:
Lawyer and social activist Siti Kasim said: "I recently saw a TikTok video where he (Akmal) was seen calling the Malays to be ready. He was seen sharpening a parang ... this is something the police must act on.
"It is like he is instigating the Malays to create problems. Islam never teaches us all this," said Siti.
No News Is Bad News reproduces below an opinion piece by Sabah’s Tuaran MP Wilfred Madius Tangau published by The Vibes and our earlier posting on the issue:
OPINION
Stop the KK witch-hunt, save Malaysia, the ringgit and Madani – Wilfred Madius Tangau
The crux of the matter in the persisting witch-hunt on KK Supermart is proportionality, says Tuaran MP.
A view of a KK Super Mart outlet’s signage. – Facebook pic, March 27, 2024.
SOME politicians and opinion leaders try to frame the polemic over the Allah-worded socks as one of non-Muslims dictating what should constitute offences to Muslims.
This is a red herring as most of the objections are not on the offence, but the proportionality of punishment.
As a Sabahan with many Muslim friends and relatives, I fully empathise with Muslims’ anger and sadness upon finding the word Allah on the stockings.
We should all adhere to the wisdom that ‘to each his own’ and respect every religious congregation or cultural community’s right to decide what constitute offensive acts.
I too feel offended whenever people who are non-Christian and non-Borneo native patronisingly tell us that ‘all religions prohibit consumption of alcohol’, not knowing that role of wine in holy communion or the centrality of rice wine (tapai, tuak), rice spirit (Montokud, Langkau) and palm wine (Bahar) in native cultures and folk beliefs.
The issue is proportionality, not offence
The crux of the matter in the persisting witch-hunt on KK Supermart is however proportionality, a key principle in the rule of law. Disproportionate punishments are unjust, and the resultant injustice provokes disobedience of laws.
Causing a person’s death is a grave crime, but why do we have different punishments for that in the Penal Code? The penalties vary from death or 30-40 years of imprisonment and whipping for murder [Section 302], maximum 30 years of imprisonment with or without fine for culpable homicide with intention [Section 304 (a)], maximum 10 years of imprisonment, fine or both for culpable homicide without intention [Section 304(b)] and maximum two years of imprisonment, fine or both for ‘causing death by negligence’ [Section 304A].
The key criterion here in determining severity of punishment is intention, not public wrath. Unintended harms must be punished less than the intended ones. Negligence must not be equated to malice. This is why we have laws and courts to determine facts including presence of malice.
Did KK Mart or its supplier Xin Jian Chang Sdn Bhd intentionally sell or import the Allah-worded socks? Both the KK Mart and Xin Jiang Chang have denied that and apologised immediately.
Why is their negligence treated as malice? Why demand or instruct both to close down? If disproportionality can be justified in the name of religion, then Umno Youth chief Akmal Saleh must demand an apology from China for allowing Mu Mian Qing Hosiery Co Ltd in Yiwu, Zhejiang Province to produce those Allah-worded socks.
Akmal should press Foreign Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Hassan, also his party’s deputy chair, to summon China’s ambassador for an explanation and to boycott China if Malaysia does not get her a satisfactory answer. In fact, shouldn’t Malaysia speak up for the Muslim world, since, in the foreign minister’s own words, “printing the holy word of “Allah” on socks directly insults Muslims everywhere.
It is a desecration of the central belief of more than 1.5 billion people?
Of course, reasonable Malaysians do not actually expect the foreign minister to act disproportionately against China which is everywhere in Malaysia’s economy from the East Coast Rail Line (ECRL) to Forest City because that would be an economic disaster.
An opportunity to promote inclusion
Why are then KK and Xin Jiang Chang being attacked disproportionately? Why are even denouncements of over-reaction slammed on the pretext of defending Islam, subtly implying that such criticisms were made by non-Muslims because they don’t understand Islam? (exactly opposite to their denial, this line is subtly racialising the issue)
Sadly, these are done by leaders of government parties, not just Akmal of Umno Youth, Mohd Hasbie Muda of Amanah Youth, PKR Youth even higher up.
Fortunately, we have also heard sober and compassionate voices from within the Muslim community that prevent the issue from being further racialised.
Penang mufti Datuk Seri Wan Salim Wan Mohd Noor, former Wanita Umno chief cum former minister of international trade and industry Tan Sri Rafidah Aziz, the boss of Mydin hypermarket Datuk Ameer Ali Mydin Datuk Ameer Ali Mydin asked, “both KK Mart and the vendor have apologised. What else do you expect them to do?”
Most impressively, within Umno, its Johor Youth chief Noor Azleen Ambro, invites Malaysians to think positively, “if we can accept that it was a genuine and honest mistake”, then the incident opens up an opportunity for mutual understanding.
To counter the bad press and rebuild goodwill, perhaps KK (whose boss Dato’ KK Chua is a Bornean Malaysian from Sarawak) and Xin Jian Chang can sponsor charity works targeting the Muslims, with the support of Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia (Jakim) and mufti offices.
To prevent repetition of such incidents, perhaps KK and Xin Jian Chang can review their standard operating procedure (SOP) to have an “equity, diversity and inclusion” (EDI) quality control officer to look out for and eliminate offensive products and practices, and a reward mechanism for any staff reporting them.
Perhaps this should be expanded throughout the business sector that cross-cultural sensitivity is more consciously nurtured through EDI training as part of the “environmental, social and governance” (ESG) best practices for Malaysian firms. Here, the National Human Rights Commission (Suhakam), National Unity Ministry and Jakim can all play a role. In fact, we should promote this to political parties and NGOs which, unlike businesses, often have incentives to offend others to score brownie points.
More than understanding, this can be an opportunity to promote inclusion across the board, in line with the government’s Madani value system.
Adverse impacts on Malaysia, ringgit and Madani
I hope Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim can see the danger of prolonging the KK witchhunt and order five ministers in-charge of (a) national unity; (b) Islamic affairs; (c) home affairs; (d) investment, trade and industry; and (e) domestic trade and cost of living to put their heads together to deescalate and end this crisis.
Let the fire burn, and the collateral damage would be Malaysia, the ringgit and the Madani government, alongside KK and Xin Jian Chang.
The witch-hunt can bring greater fear of non-Muslims towards Islam, but not more love or respect. This is bad for both Malaysia and Islam.
In fact, many Borneo Malaysians increasingly find Malaya a horrifying foreign land. The witch-hunt will defeat the government’s efforts to bring in foreign investment and stabilise ringgit. We have been told that ringgit is undervalued, as our fundamentals are strong and only market confidence is weak.
My foreign friends in the business community are watching the developments in horror. If negligence can lead to a death sentence for a retail chain that is planning to go for IPO, what would protect their investment from rouge competitors or extorting law-enforcers?
What would they take the risk of building up a business only to be destroyed or harvested by others? More than losing foreign investments, we may see capital flight from even domestic investors.
Finally, the witch hunt will hurt the Madani government in GE16, if not earlier. Even with economic growth, a moderate government in Malaysia will have a tough time satisfying various segments of voters.
If the ringgit continues to plummet, and the non-Muslims feel helpless before Muslim vigilantism, one can expect capital flight and low turnout. With the Kota Kubu Baru by-election in the corner, things already look a bit similar to Tanjung Piai.
Geographically speaking, East Malaysia is the mainland Malaysia, which I am going to refer to as the other Malaysia
If the ethno-populism in Malaya is not put under control, notwithstanding the government’s hard work in courting foreign investments, Malaysia will gradually lose the race to Indonesia, Vietnam and Thailand.
To avoid being dragged to the bottom by Malaya, Sabah and Sarawak should cultivate a clear branding as the Other Malaysia, which are geographically identified as Mainland Malaysia, one that is reasonable, stable, inclusive, and at ease with diversity.
We should prepare ourselves to attract both foreign investments coming to Malaysia and also domestic investments leaving Malaya. What we lack in infrastructure and human resources, we shall make it up with our openness.
While we Borneans and or Malaysian mainlanders are not good in producing grand narratives and slogans, we have been the real “Madani” (at least in compassion, respect and trust) country even before Malaysia was formed. Moderation is our middle name.
I hope Sabah Chief Minister Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor and Sarawak Premier Tan Sri Abang Jo can see both the crisis and opportunity we are in.
Both states should aggressively enhance EDI and cosmopolitanism at home and set up trade and investment office overseas. If Malaya insists to play with fire, Borneo must grow faster as a safe haven for investments and talents. – The Vibes, March 27, 2024.
Datuk Seri Panglima Wilfred Madius Tangau is the Tuaran MP and honorary president of Upko.
Monday 25 March 2024
Made-in-China Allah-brand socks: What about China and the Customs officer who let in the socks?
Share to help stimulate good governance, ensure future of people & M’sia
No News Is Bad News
What about Allah sandals? Not insulting? Why no such amok reactions like the KK Mart Made-China Allah-brand socks?
Made-in-China Allah-brand socks: What about China and the Customs officer who let in the socks?
KUALA LUMPUR, March 26, 2024: Yes! The racist and religious bigoted Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh and his party are just bullies who care a damn about national unity and harmony.
In behaving so, they also destroy Malaysia’s image as a premier investment country.
Akmal and Umno have succeeded in bullying the Chinese-owned KK Mart until its owners are charged in court.
But they lost their “balls” when it comes to China.
Why are they not going after China for a public apology for manufacturing the socks, and also the Customs di-Raja Malaysia for allowing the “insulting-Muslim socks” into the country?
Clearly a case of selective persecution and prosecution against KK Mart.
Clearly to all sane Malaysians, ther bigoted Akmal and Umno are just stirring up the Made-in-China Allah-brand socks issue just for political mileage.
No News Is Bad News reproduces below a news report on the issue:
‘Bully’ Akmal won’t dare go after China, says academic
-26 Mar 2024, 11:15 AM
Tajuddin Rasdi labels the Umno Youth chief as an ‘opportunist’ attempting to garner personal support.
Academic Tajuddin Rasdi says Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh is taking advantage of the controversy surrounding the sale of socks with the word ‘Allah’. (Bernama pic)
PETALING JAYA: An academic says Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh will not go to the extent of pursuing an apology from China regarding the “Allah” socks issue despite calling for a boycott of convenience chain store KK Mart over the matter.
Speaking to FMT, Tajuddin Rasdi of UCSI University said Akmal was unlikely to summon the Chinese ambassador following a challenge by Tuaran MP Wilfred Madius Tangau for him to demand an apology from China for allowing the manufacturer to produce the socks.
“A bully will always pick on a smaller person,” Tajuddin said.
“He may continue to dwell on the issue because he doesn’t care about the future consequences or the welfare of (KK Mart’s) workers.
“That’s no longer just being a bully; that’s being an opportunist.”
In a statement yesterday, Tangau said Akmal should press foreign minister and Umno deputy president Mohamad Hasan to summon China’s ambassador for an explanation if Malaysia does not get a satisfactory answer.
He also said that Akmal’s response was akin to “grasping at straws” in an attempt to win support and popularity for himself and the party as a whole.
“This is simply an exercise in sacrificing 5,000 jobs to be noticed and for Umno to be popular with the Malays once again,” he said.
Meanwhile, former Sungai Benut MP Tawfik Ismail said Akmal’s hypothetical summoning of the ambassador would tarnish Malaysia’s reputation.
“It would make us look ridiculous. The whole thing would make us look rather shallow and narrow-minded,” he said.
He said Tangau’s comments merely highlighted a potential situation where the youth leader would demand explanations from all parties involved in the sale of the socks, from the manufacturer to the salesman.
“What he’s trying to say is, ‘What would happen if Akmal goes after everybody along the supply chain, all the way up to the factory in China?’,” he said.
The former MP added that if such action were to be taken against all parties involved, it would affect mainly Malay Muslims.
“Don’t forget that when the socks were produced and brought into Malaysia, they had to go through customs. Why doesn’t he go for the customs officer that allowed the socks to come through?” he said.
“After all, those customs officers are Malay Muslims. Are you going to blame them as well for what happened?”
Sunday 24 March 2024
Made-in-China Allah-brand socks insulting Islam? What about Allah sandals?
Share to help stimulate good governance, ensure future of people & M’sia
No News Is Bad News
Made-in-China Allah-brand socks insulting Islam? What about Allah sandals?
KUALA LUMPUR, March 24, 2024: No News Is Bad News found the above image posted on Facebook.
And the image featured this comment:
And this was in Johore, sandals with the Allah word and no fuss about it.
It seems only they could say anything about their Allah. Non Muslims must have no say. After all, I respect all religions as my belief is there is only one True GOD - our CREATOR !
Prayers of worships and offerings may differ from race to race, religion to religion only!
I truly do not believe there are different Thien Kong , Allah, Samy , or Tuhan or GOD the Almighty or whatever names we named HIM differ from different race or creed !
No News Is Bad News is refraining from further comments. We let the images do the talking.
And, the following was also posted on Facebook:
As long as the word is not at the sole of feet, there is no disrespect.
So it takes wisdom to understand what is respect and disrespect.
Don’t insult any religion, minister urges netizens
-24 Mar 2024, 10:04 PM
Religious affairs minister Na’im Mokhtar, citing the Quran, says Muslims are forbidden from insulting others or their faiths.
Na’im Mokhtar says every member of Malaysia’s multicultural and multi-religious society should actively work towards fostering unity. (Bernama pic)
KUALA LUMPUR: Religious affairs minister Na’im Mokhtar has urged the public to refrain from making derogatory remarks about religion on social media, as this would create hostilities in Malaysian society.
He said it is important for every member of the nation’s multicultural and multi-religious society to actively work towards fostering unity. They should leverage social media for this purpose.
“In the context of the Quran and Islam, it’s expressly forbidden for Muslims to insult others or their religions,” he told the media after officiating a Ramadan event of the Federal Territories Islamic Religious Council.
Na’im also urged the public to prioritise national security and prevent actions that may strain ties or incite anger among the different religious communities.
No comments:
Post a Comment